A New Year for Dialysis—Home and In-Center

This blog post was made by Dori Schatell, MS, Executive Director, Medical Education Institute on January 1st, 2015.
A New Year for Dialysis—Home and In-Center

Like 2013, 2014 sped by in a flash and now we have a new, shiny 2015 to look forward to. The FDA’s approval of the NxStage System One for nocturnal home hemodialysis (HD) finally came through! Now, the path is cleared for more Americans to get the most dialysis possible at a time that allows them to spend their days as they choose. Let 2015 be the year of nocturnal home HD!

And, let 2015 be the year that U.S. in-center dialysis outcomes catch up with the rest of the world. There are a few other realities I’d love to see us face as a renal community to make that happen. The 2-day no-treatment gap for standard in-center HD is one of them. In 1999, Bleyer et al[1] did an analysis of 20 years worth of U.S. deaths on dialysis by day of the week, using USRDS data (n=375,482). There was no effect for PD—folks using that treatment were just about as likely to die on a Monday as a Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday or Sunday. Not so for standard in-center HD. Instead, the pattern looked a lot like this (MWF folks on the left, and TRS on the right). You can see that the risk of cardiac death was 50% higher on the day after the 2-day “killer gap”:

Description: BEACON:Users:dori:Desktop:Screen Shot 2014-12-27 at 8.57.38 PM.png

Text Box: All-cause cardiac deaths

The same researchers (and a few extra) hypothesized that death rates would be highest in the 12 hours before and after the treatments around the 2-day gap.[2] And, that’s just what they found.

So, if someone had a treatment on a Friday morning at 8 am, the rate of sudden cardiac death until Friday night at 8 pm was 70% higher—and from 8 pm on Sunday night until Monday morning, the rate was triple:

A 2012 DOPPS paper by Zhang et al had similar findings—most pronounced in the U.S. Among the 2,663 American dialysis deaths reported, MWF patients were 41% more likely to die on Mondays, and TRS patients were 39% more likely to die on Tuesdays.[3]

What does all this tell us? That Dr. Carl Kjellstrand is right—unphysiology kills. We’ve known for 16 years that going two days in a row with no treatment is a lethal way to dialyze, but we still do it. He estimated in a keynote address at the Annual Dialysis Conference a few years ago that 10,000 Americans die each year solely due to the 2-day “killer gap. ” If dialysis providers would change to a 2-week rotation of every other day treatments, more moms and dads could watch their children grow to adulthood, and more grandchildren could spend time with their grandparents .

CMS can pay for every other day treatments, so providers could charge for 26 extra treatments each year x 400,000 people—or about $2.3 billion a year. (This cost would be partially—if not entirely—offset by fewer hospitalizations, but the Medicare Part A/Part B “wall” (separate buckets of U.S. Federal money for inpatient vs. outpatient care—for our International readers) won’t account for that. Hmm. Why don’t we tear that down in 2015, too?)

Yes, transportation and assigning work shifts to create an every-other-day schedule will be a hassle. But, are those good enough reasons not to save people who would die otherwise? Why not start every-other-day dialysis in 2015? One of the best things about most home dialysis is that it gets rid of that killer gap.

And…a couple of other things I would fix about in-center HD if I were the Queen of Dialysis (so those folks have a better chance to live long enough to switch to home treatments or get a transplant):

  • Give everyone who is dialyzing in-center at least 4-hour treatments. A startling stat I ran across in the Zhang et al DOPPS paper referenced above is that the annual mortality rate on dialysis in the U.S. is 23%—but it’s 15% in Europe, and just 9% in Japan. 3 Our ultrashort treatments (averaging just 214 minutes)[4] are part of the reason for this. We’re not getting to the “middle molecules” that may be responsible for neuropathy and bone damage down the road. And, we are damaging fistulas by running the blood pump too fast to keep treatments short. Let’s measure the right things! “ Great labs” are not enough for people to feel well and live fully.
  • Slow down ultrafiltration. We are causing painful cramping and stunning the kidneys, the heart, the brains of our patients. Jennifer Flythe’s work on mortality by ultrafiltration rate (UFR) is—pardon the pun—stunning.[5] It’s clear that rates over 10mL/Kg/Hr. are lethal (you can see it in the graph below). The Chief Medical Officers of all of the providers agree.[6] It’s fluid that kills. We know this. Let’s slow UFRs in 2015! (While we’re slowing down UFRs, we need to stop nagging at and blaming patients for drinking too much without examining the relationship to fluid weight gains from sodium modeling in dialysis , using saline or salty broth to treat blood pressure drops, and ignoring thirst side effects in routinely prescribed medications.) While we’re at it, let’s toss out Kt/V, which is pretty well worthless. Optimal dialysis is so much more important than “adequate.” Dr. Agar has even developed a calculator to use for a volume-based kidney performance indicator.

Description: BEACON:Users:dori:Desktop:Screen Shot 2014-12-28 at 11.12.01 AM.png

Annually the U.S. renal community pats itself on the back for declining mortality rates, and we have made some necessary progress. However, nearly one quarter of all new HD patients still die in the first 12 months, and just 39.8% of prevalent standard in-center HD patients survive for 5 years . We know that standard in-center HD patients who are younger, Black, and who have kidney failure due to glomerulonephritis have higher survival rates.[7] Let’s put our heads together and study WHY certain HD patients survive longer and use what we learn to improve survival for all HD patients. Those who put their lives in our hands deserve no less—in 2015 and every year.



[1] Bleyer AJ, Russell GB, Satko SG. Sudden and cardiac death rates in hemodialysis patients. Kidney Int, 1999; 55:1553-9

[2] Bleyer AJ, Hartman J, Brannon PC, Reeves-Daniel A, Satko SG, Russell G. Characteristics of sudden death in hemodialysis patients. Kidney Int. 2006;69(12):2268-73

[3] Zhang H, Schaubel DE, Kalbfleisch JD, Bragg-Gresham JL, Robinson BM, Pisoni RL, Canaud B, Jadoul M, Akiba T, Saito A, Port FK, Saran R. Dialysis outcomes and analysis of practice patterns suggests the dialysis schedule affects day-of-week mortality. Kidney Int. 2012;81:1108-15

[4] Tentori F, Zhang J, Li Y, Karaboyas A, Kerr P, Saran R, Bommer J, Port F, Akiba T, Pisoni R, Robinson B. Longer dialysis session length is associated with better intermediate outcomes and survival among patients on in-center three times per week hemodialysis: results from the Dialysis Outcomes and Practice Patterns Study (DOPPS). Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2012;27:4180-8

[5] Flythe JE, Kimmel SE, Brunelli SM. Rapid fluid removal during dialysis is associated with cardiovascular morbidity and mortality. Kidney Int. 2011;79(2):250-7

[6] Weiner DE, Brunelli SM, Hunt A, Schiller B, Glassock R, Maddux FW, Johnson D, Parker T, Nissenson A. Improving clinical outcomes among hemodialysis patients: a proposal for a “volume first” approach from the Chief Medical Officers of US Dialysis Providers. Am J Kidney Dis. 2014;64(5):685-95

[7] United States Renal Data System, 2014 Annual Data Report: Epidemiology of Kidney Disease in the United States. National Institutes of Health, National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases, Bethesda, MD, 2014.

Comments

  • Patti Anne

    Feb 12, 2:26 PM

    Dori, thanks for all you do. I am fairly new to this website and am very impressed by it.

    I love your ideas posted on this page. We need to let the dialysis community know how they can help move your ideas forward. I would think that most of us have no idea on how we can help in that effort.

    Reply to this Comment

    * All fields are required.

    1. Your email will not be displayed publicly
  • Lana Schmidt

    Jan 2, 12:13 PM

    Keep pushing on these issues & keep shouting it from the rooftops!

    Reply to this Comment

    * All fields are required.

    1. Your email will not be displayed publicly
  • Susan Emeny

    Jan 2, 11:32 AM

    Well put Dori!

    Reply to this Comment

    * All fields are required.

    1. Your email will not be displayed publicly
Leave a New Comment

* All fields are required.

  1. Your email will not be displayed publicly